[Source or answer dispute] Official B: claim-made fact conflicts

What you will learn

Disputed-question explanation: official result first, then historical evidence, limitations and uncertainty.

October 23, 2024 CBLE full text extracted from exam2024.pdf (exam pages 1–33 and answer key pages 34–36): question 48 stem, all facts and all four options.; Question 48 options as extracted (PDF page 24).; Cover directions and prescribed references of the October 23, 2024 CBLE.; Answer key row 48 in the same file (key pages 34–36).; Original combined exam and key PDF (36 pages), cached locally and read in full; not inaccessible. Per conflict-batch04 review.md the CBP download returned 403 at review time and this copy came from the mirror https://www.lawcustoms.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/102024CBLE.pdf; recorded as found. PDF pages 1, 23, 24 and 35 rendered locally to /tmp/q48png and physically viewed by this author. Image source; excerpt is this author's transcription.; Review PNG of exam PDF page 23 (calendar and question 48 facts), physically viewed by this author; matches the local render.; 19 CFR 142.12(b), Title 19 CFR 2023 annual edition (XML DATE 2023-04-01, ORIGINALDATE 2022-04-01). Cross-read against the official annual package PDF video-pilot/source-evidence/2024oct/CFR-2023-part142-resume4749.pdf (SHA-256 4408e71c30c4bb75899b17662eb5672d5d2c4303270212802d6004bf769ed6e3; govinfo CFR-2023-title19-vol2-part142; printed page 51, header '4–1–22 Edition').; 19 CFR 141.101 complete section (introductory text and (a)–(e)) from the 2023 annual package Part 141 PDF (govinfo CFR-2023-title19-vol2-part141; printed page 42, header '4–1–22 Edition'). PDF SHA-256 85459d2821f9f47e4036c0d00e8858ffc61a464d4f72ebe2490cf31e6eba76d9.; 19 CFR 174.11 complete section, 2023 annual edition (XML DATE 2023-04-01); cross-read against the official annual package Part 174 PDF video-pilot/source-evidence/2024oct/CFR-2023-part174-resume4749.pdf (SHA-256 add8d6e60808b0ea8def6715c1d3073fc5b8aa555e151abf38788b3c7084263a; printed pages 355–356).; 19 CFR 174.11(b)(5).; 19 CFR 174.12(e), 2023 annual edition (XML DATE 2023-04-01); cross-read against Part 174 PDF printed pages 356–357.; 19 CFR 182.31 complete section, 2023 annual edition (XML DATE 2023-04-01); cross-read against the official annual package Part 182 PDF video-pilot/source-evidence/2024oct/CFR-2023-part182-resume4749.pdf (SHA-256 851cb45df171a74bdaf0a8a03b5508db40f03247fcd6b398de2b73c428d15217; printed page 530). §§182.32 (filing procedures) and 182.33 (CBP processing, allowance and denial) read in full on pages 530–531.; 19 CFR 182.33(d)(1) denial grounds (complete §182.33 read).; 19 CFR 171.12 as printed in a cached Part 171 PDF text. The file name says CFR-2022, but its page headers read '19 CFR Ch. I (4–1–22 Edition)' with typeset line 'Jan 31, 2023', the same edition text and typeset line as the cached 2023 annual-package Parts 141/142/174/182. No provenance record for this file was found, so its package identity is not independently confirmed. Used only to explain the key's '171.12(e)' citation.; Conflict batch04 review, section '2024oct-48 — official B' and full original/key extract '### 2024oct48'. Report only; primary files above were read directly.; Pipeline Codex independent primary-source review, item 2024oct-48 (conditions_missing_hold). · October 23, 2024 Customs Broker License Examination, 'CBP Publication: 3887-1124' (as printed); answer key 'October 23, 2024 Customs Broker License Exam Answer Key', 'CBP Publication: 3888-1124' (as printed). Exam reference per cover: Title 19, Code of Federal Regulations (2023 Revised as of April 1, 2023), Parts 141 to 199. Texts used: 2023 annual edition §§141.101, 142.12, 174.11, 174.12, 182.31–182.33 (pages carry the '4–1–22 Edition' text, typeset Jan 31, 2023); the exam's own 2024 calendar. §171.12 read only from a cached '4–1–22 Edition' Part 171 text whose package identity is unconfirmed, to explain the key citation. 19 U.S.C. 1520(d) statute text not read. No 2024 or later CFR, current rule, supplement or current total duty is used; no duty is computed.
Explained using the historical edition for this exam.